What an incredible show last night in Milwaukee. I'll likely post a full length review, but here's the setlist as I can recall off the top of my head:

Message
B.J.
"Luge night" improv
Horseshoes
If Only...
I Love My Boss
You Will Go to the Moon
When She Talks
Pisco Bandito
Boo Time
Misstra Know-It-All
Independence Day
Michigan Militia
Present Tense
Johnny Saucep'n
River Valley
Get in the Car
Boyfriend
Psycho Killer

E1:
Authors
Dancing Queen

E2:
I Will Hold On
Poor Generation

• I've Gotta Get a Message to You (A Cappella)

• B.J. Don't Cry
• 'Luge Night' [improv]
• Horseshoes
• If Only You Knew
• I Love My Boss
• You Will Go to the Moon
• When She Talks
• Pisco Bandito
• Boo Time (Jazz Version)
• Mistra Know-It-All
• Independence Day
• Michigan Militia
• The Present Tense Tureen
• Johnny Saucep'n
• River Valley
• Get in the Car
• Your New Boyfriend

• Psycho Killer

• My Baby Loves a Bunch of Authors
• Dancing Queen Medley

• I Will Hold On
• My Poor Generation

Some other tidbits from the performance include:

• Feel free to help contribute to this section!